If you’re a longtime fan of the Bachelor Franchise, you may recognize Susie from The Bachelor Season 26, where she famously rejected Clayton Echard’s proposal. By the time the finale and After the Final Rose special aired, the two had gotten back together. But they announced their breakup on Instagram in September 2022.

Bachelor in Paradise season 10 has introduced a lot of firsts - a new location, new producers, and for the first time, contestants from The Golden Bachelor intermingling with younger Bachelor and Bachelorette contestants.

"Bachelor in Paradise" season 10 is heating up with the arrival of the "Golden" contestants. Here's what happened on this week's dramatic episodes.

Bachelor in Paradise’s Justin Glaze stands by giving his rose to ex Susie Evans, sharing his thoughts on her decline and Lexi Young romance

He had to choose between Lexi and his ex, Susie Evans. We’re only two episodes deep into Bachelor in Paradise season 10, and the cast is already getting into some (on and off-camera) drama. It’s exactly what we’re tuned in for.

Upcoming ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Bombshell, 31, Stuns Fans With Her Unexpected Return: ‘Jaw Dropped’ first appeared on Parade on Jul 11, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jul 11, 2025, where it first appeared.